• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Diet Nutrition Exercise

  • Home
  • About Me

Weight Loss Fallacies: 2lbs per week and 1200 calories per day

May 22, 2017 By johnbarban

I received an email the other day that sums up how popular diet/fitness misinformation can leave people frustrated, upset, angry and eventually to flat out give up on the idea of getting in shape.

So the email went something like this:

“I just read your book and it says my RMR is approx 1250 calories. I want to lose 2lbs per week because that is supposed to be a realistic weight loss goal…but to do that you say you have to create a 1000 calorie deficit each day, that means I can only eat 250 calories per day…but I also heard that you should never eat below 1200 calories per day…so how is this possible?!”

What is a realistic weight loss goal?

Of course I’m paraphrasing and this is not the exact words, but this is a very typical email I get every week.

There are a few different flaws and fallacies in this statement…did you notice them? If not, I’ll show you.

Fallacy #1. There is no scientific proof that 2lbs per week of weight loss is a safe or realistic goal that all adults humans can or should expect to achieve. This is a claim based on FTC advertising standards. You only hear this number because marketers aren’t allowed to say any more by law. If they could the number would likely be 10lbs per week. That doesn’t make it any more or less correct, because neither number is based on scientific evidence.

A 6’5 260lbs man can easily expect to lose up to even 4lbs per week, however a 5’1 woman is hardly in the same position. Instead of setting a weight loss goal based on poundage (ie: 1lbs, 2lbs, 3lbs per week) you should be looking at it as a percentage of your bodyweight.

A 6’0 tall man who weights 220lbs with a RMR of approximately 2000 cals/day could easily create a 1000 calorie deficit each day by cutting his calories to 1500/day and burning an additional 500 calories in a good hard workout (mix of weights and cardio).

1500 is still plenty of calories to feel relatively satisfied while still creating a fair sized deficit to facilitate a significant weekly weight loss.

Also 2lbs of weight loss represents less than 1% of his total bodyweight.

Now change the person to a 5’1 woman with an RMR of 1250 calories. She would have to eat around 750 calories per day as well as burning off an additional 500 in the gym. This is starting to sound more like torture than a reasonable diet plan.

The fallacy is that 2lbs is a good target for all body sizes…it is not. Smaller people have smaller metabolisms and shouldn’t expect to lose as much total weight as a bigger person. It would be more realistic for her to shoot for 1lbs of weight loss which would only require a 500 calorie daily deficit…this could be achieved with a much more reasonably daily calorie intake around 1000 calories with a 250 calorie burn from a workout. Doesn’t that sound much more realistic?!

Fallacy #2: 1200 calories is the minimum you should eat in a day

I don’t know where this number comes from and I will be spending some time in the near future looking it up. However based on the RDI and RDA for nutrients the actual lower limit for calories (when you add up the individual recommendations for protein, carbs and fats) comes out to around 800 calories per day for women and 900 for men. So even according to the RDA you can easily eat well below 1200 and get your daily requirements of protein carbs and fats.

These two false assumptions are leading many people down a path of frustration and weight loss failure.

Setting realistic weight loss goals is the first step to success.

Letting go of your fear of eating less food is the second step.

Once you realize it’s ok to eat a bit less food then you will start to see things really change.

John

Filed Under: Calories, Weight Loss Tagged With: eating less than 1200 calories per day, losing 2lbs per week

PROMOTED STORIES:
  • 6 Weeks To Six Pack Abs That Are As Hot As They Are “Deadly”
  • Are The Foods You Eat Triggering Health-Harming “Obesity Toxins” In Your Gut?
  • Trick Your Body Into Burning Fat Like You're On A Low Carb Diet - While You Eat Yummy Carbs Every Day
  • In Just One Day This Simple Strategy Frees You From Complicated Diet Rules — And Eliminates Rebound Weight Gain
  • New Discovery "Flips The OFF Switch" on Stubborn Fat
  • Discover The Surprising Connection Between Exhaustion, Lethargy, Weight Gain and The Air You Breathe
  • How To Unlock Your Instinctive Skills For Devastating Violence In Just A Few Hours — Without ANY Martial Arts Training
  • Revealed: Your Answer To The Most Frustrating Nutrition Myth Of The Past Decade “How Much And What Kind Of Protein Do You REALLY Need To Eat Every Day?”

Primary Sidebar

Java Burn

Get Java Burn

Tea Burn

Get Tea Burn

Subscribe to posts feed
Subscribe to comments

Recommended Posts

How Much Protein Is In An Egg?

Eggs are an excellent source of protein and relatively cheap too. They have a very high biological value and a full complement of essential and non-essential amino acids. In short, if you wanted a complete and easy to absorb protein source look no further than eggs. With that said there are a few considerations you […]

Steroid Muscle vs Natural Muscle

So I guess the general theme this week is “hormones”. So the next topic that we’re going to cover was sent in by Jason and this is about steroid muscle vs natural muscle. This is a tricky topic because most celebrities, athletes and bodybuilders don’t admit or disclose the drugs they use so it’s hard […]

Eugen Sandow vs Arnold Schwarzenegger - Gold Standard Bodybuilders before and after steroids were discovered

A Steroid Free Bodybuilder You Can Trust – Eugen Sandow

Here is a good comparison picture of Eugen Sandow vs Arnold Schwarzenegger. Eugen Sandow is known as the first real bodybuilder and gained international fame for doing the first bodybuilding style poses for crowds of people. The interesting thing is that he died 10 years before testosterone was discovered… so you know he could have […]

Bodyfat Distribution Patterns

Body fat is distributed all over your body but it’s not an even distribution. For example there is a at least a little bit of fat stored in places like your forehead and the back of your hands, but obviously this isn’t a major fat storage site. For men the main site of fat storage […]

Can You Workout Through Muscle Soreness?

Question: Can I still workout if my muscles are sore? Answer: It Depends. I get this question all the time about working out through muscle soreness and the answer is that it depends. Depends on how sore your muscles really are, depends on what you’re planning on doing in the gym while you feel this […]

Danger Metabolism Slowing Ahead

Unless you have a degree in human biology …and in many cases even if you do… you do not understand what “metabolism” means. This word gets thrown around the fitness and diet media and is used to scare people into thinking there is a dangerous level of calories that will destroy their metabolism. This of […]

Using Growth Hormone For Fat Loss

Growth Hormone is a commonly abused drug in the bodybuilding culture. Although it’s name might make you think it is primarily responsible for muscle growth, it is actually used to help with recovery and above all, fat burning. In order to burn fat your body needs to have high growth hormone levels and low insulin levels. […]

How To Gain 1 Pound of FAT!

This past weekend was thanksgiving for us folks up in Canada. (I have no idea why we have a different date for this…actually, I don’t even know why we celebrate it…but whatever.) Anyway, needless to say there was lots of food and I ate a lot of food. And then I got to thinking. How […]

What Does “Healthy” Look Like?

I met up with a friend for my morning coffee today and we got onto the topic of body image (go figure) and we ended up talking about what a healthy body looks like. This is when I realized that we all have a built in image in our heads of what we think a […]

The Ultimate Stress Test

The response to the coronavirus has presented us with what could be considered the biggest stress test of ourselves individually and of our societies collectively. On one hand our life stresses have increased due to a lack of certainly about our financial futures, the political future, and what the future holds for our families, friends […]

Archive

Resurge

Get Resurge Now






Get a copy of my book “Thinking Thin” for FREE here!

We respect your email privacy

Footer

About John Barban

Hi I’m John Barban and here is some stuff you might find useful/interesting about me and what this blog is all about Read more...

Privacy and Terms

Privacy Policy and Cookies
Terms and Conditions
Copyright © johnbarban.com
Cleantalk Pixel